5 Comments
User's avatar
Jonathan Gibbs's avatar

None more, but equalling Cheever's story on six times are:

The Bloody Chamber by Angela Carter

The Husband Stitch by Carmen Maria Machado

The Dead by James Joyce

Bliss by Katherine Mansfield

Smote, or When I Find I Cannot Kiss You In Front Of A Print By Bridget Riley’ by Eley Williams

Car Crash While Hitchhiking by Denis Johnson

Expand full comment
Connla Stokes's avatar

What a great list and so many I haven’t read -- i was sure someone would choose the Swimmer by Cheever but I have read about that story enough so I am not sad it didn’t get yet another shout out.

Expand full comment
Jonathan Gibbs's avatar

Ha! Well The Swimmer has been picked six times as part of people's Personal Anthologies over the years - not for a Summer Special, though. The Cheever story that HAS been picked for a Summer Anthology is 'The Seaside Houses': https://apersonalanthology.com/2021/07/02/the-seaside-houses-by-john-cheever/

Expand full comment
Connla Stokes's avatar

Wow, six times. Actually I am not surprised. Has any story been picked more?

Expand full comment
Tom McGohey's avatar

Some other stories I considered:

* The Pool Sharks, Ursula Curtiss (menacing without actually bursting into violence you expect)

* The Summer People, Shirley Jackson

* The Death of the Right Fielder, Stuart Dybek (the existentialism of childhood baseball)

* The Adventure of the Bather, Italo Calvino (every swimmer’s worst nightmare -- well, more like second worst)

* No Place for You, My Love, Eudora Welty (sets standard for stories of illusory love)

* The Steppe, Chekhov (ok it’s really a novella, not a short story, but a highly under-appreciated work, IMHO)

* A Long Fourth, Peter Taylor (actually never read this one, an embarrassing omission given that I’m a Taylor fan)

Expand full comment